Sometimes, in conversations about race, I wonder what is going through people's HEADS. I mean, I'm white. I get assloads of white privilege every day and in every way. And I fuck up. TRUST me, I fuck up bad sometimes and I feel like an idiot and people call me on it and I apologize and I try to learn.
And then I see shit like
Patricia Wrede's Thirteenth Child, a book that takes the premise of an alternate version of our world which is full of magic, and where America (“Columbia”) was discovered empty of people but full of dangerous animals, many of them magical.
No people. Fully erasing the genocide and slavery that America was built on, but no. No, there are ANIMALS. AND THEY'RE MAGICAL. AND DANGEROUS.
So let me get this straight. To begin with, there is a complete erasure of indigenous peoples in North America - they're simply gone. It's certainly possible (even likely) that the author did not know about or intend to fall into it, but this furthers a longstanding pattern of invisibility, silencing, othering, and ignoring of indigenous peoples in North America.
Because, largely, Americans act as if our country has no history before Christopher Columbus. We act as if the beginning point of this landmass, of "our people" starts when white people landed, when white people killed, when white people destroyed. Sure, a part of the reason we do it is because we're trained that way and part of the reason we're trained that way is because of racial and cultural shame about the widespread genocide that built this country.
So we kill entire tribes, decimate families. We take lands. We treat indigenous people like animals for most of our country's history. We lie, we cheat, we steal. We give them smallpox blankets.
And then we make them invisible. Children in many large cities may never see a person who is a tribal member or an American Indian. Most American children will never know the name or anything about a tribe that is not represented in a bad mainstream movie. They will not know about the American Indian Movement and Leonard Peltier, they will not know about Chief Cecilla Fire Thunder and the fight for reproductive freedom on the Pine Ridge Reservation.
They won't know anything about native people in our country except a deafening silence of information that is offset largely only by factually-incorrect Disney movies (I'm look at you,
Pocahontas) and mainstream movies and the occasional paragraph in their history books.
An entire book of that furthers the invisibility of indigenous people, one where Europeans are the first peoples, is a premise that continues that silencing. It's made worse, of course, by allowing the "presence" of the "magical Indian" through the dangerous, magical animals - the same things that Europeans originally thought of many of the tribes they encountered.
I don't care how well it's written, this whole premise is gross. And I'm disappointed in Tor for publishing it at all.